CHAPTER VII

SPARC rotation-curve equation adapter

All chapters

Status

Evidence class: PUBLIC_DATA_DEV_OPTIMIZATION_PLUS_HELDOUT_SHARED_ADAPTER_DIAGNOSTIC

The shared adapter parameters were selected on 14 development galaxies and frozen before seven heldout galaxies were evaluated. One heldout galaxy was excluded from the aggregate because its baseline NFW nuisance fit hit a bound, leaving 105 rotation-curve points from six baseline-stable heldout galaxies. Each galaxy, including each heldout galaxy, still received its own NFW baseline nuisance fit. This is therefore a heldout test of the shared adapter rule, not a clean end-to-end predictive test and not physical-law proof.

Public data

The lane uses the SPARC v1 galaxy sample and Newtonian mass-model rotation curves from Lelli, McGaugh & Schombert (2016), The Astronomical Journal 152, 157, DOI 10.3847/0004-6256/152/6/157. The exact source bytes are identified in DATA_PROVENANCE.md. Third-party source files are not committed.

Baseline equation

For each galaxy, fixed stellar mass-to-light coefficients of 0.5 for the disk and 0.7 for the bulge were used:

Vbar2(R)=Vgas∣Vgas∣+0.5Vdisk∣Vdisk∣+0.7Vbulge∣Vbulge∣.V_{\rm bar}^2(R)=V_{\rm gas}|V_{\rm gas}| +0.5V_{\rm disk}|V_{\rm disk}| +0.7V_{\rm bulge}|V_{\rm bulge}|.

The selected sample is bulgeless, so the bulge contribution is zero. A per-galaxy NFW halo was fitted with free V200V_{200} and concentration cc:

Vbase2(R)=Vbar2(R)+GMNFW(<R;V200,c)R.V_{\rm base}^2(R)=V_{\rm bar}^2(R) +\frac{G M_{\rm NFW}(<R;V_{200},c)}{R}.

A baseline was considered stable only if the optimizer succeeded and neither V200V_{200} nor cc hit its allowed bounds.

Equation-adapted orthogonal term

The operator acts only on the fitted three-dimensional NFW halo density. The scale is tied to each galaxy's disk scale length:

dg=ηRdisk,g,d_g=\eta R_{{\rm disk},g},
ρaug,g=(1−f)ρNFW,g+f(Kdg∗ρNFW,g),\rho_{{\rm aug},g}=(1-f)\rho_{{\rm NFW},g} +f\left(K_{d_g}*\rho_{{\rm NFW},g}\right),
Vaug2(R)=Vbar2(R)+GMaug(<R)R.V_{\rm aug}^2(R)=V_{\rm bar}^2(R) +\frac{G M_{\rm aug}(<R)}{R}.

The three-dimensional Plummer kernel is

Kd(r)=34πd3(1+r2d2)−5/2.K_d(r)=\frac{3}{4\pi d^3}\left(1+\frac{r^2}{d^2}\right)^{-5/2}.

The finite-grid convolution was deterministically rescaled to the unchanged halo mass before augmentation. The uncorrected finite-window leakage was still retained and required to remain below 2%.

Sample lock

Eligibility was fixed before scientific scoring:

  • SPARC quality flag Q = 1;
  • Hubble type T >= 7;
  • inclination from 30 to 85 degrees;
  • bulgeless mass model;
  • at least 12 rotation-curve rows;
  • positive disk scale length.

Twenty-one galaxies passed. They were ordered by SHA256(galaxy name); the first 14 were development and the final seven heldout. NGC3109 had a prior visible exploratory score and fell in the development set. Heldout score visibility before policy freeze was false. The ordered sample-ID hash is d5bb9bb18b9bbbcea0d2e31aee592d275b0aa596d32be2ed145c2494c9a3b3b5.

The full split, catalog metadata, and source-member hashes are in sparc_rotation_curve_sample_manifest.json.

Development and freeze

The dev objective was the macro mean chi-square per point across baseline-stable galaxies. The expanded grid was:

  • f∈{0,0.05,0.10,0.20,0.30,0.40,0.50,0.60,0.75,1.0}f \in \{0,0.05,0.10,0.20,0.30,0.40,0.50,0.60,0.75,1.0\};
  • η∈{0.03125,0.0625,0.125,0.25,0.5,1,2,4,8}\eta \in \{0.03125,0.0625,0.125,0.25,0.5,1,2,4,8\}.

Eleven of 14 development baselines were stable. The shared optimum was

f=1.0,η=0.125.f=1.0,\qquad \eta=0.125.

eta = 0.125 is interior to the expanded grid. f = 1.0 is the physical fraction boundary and was not extended beyond one. Under this candidate, macro chi-square per point moved from 1.0010746505 to 0.9316796428 (delta -0.0693950078), with 9/11 improved and 2/11 worsened.

The complete 90-policy grid with per-galaxy rows is preserved in sparc_rotation_curve_dev_grid.json.

Heldout result

Kernel Baseline total χ2\chi^2 Candidate total χ2\chi^2 Raw Δχ2\Delta\chi^2 Residual reduction Improved / worsened
Plummer 3D 208.844928 199.588715 -9.256213 4.432% 5 / 1
Gaussian 3D 208.844928 203.372901 -5.472027 2.620% 5 / 1
Top-hat 3D 208.844928 203.805247 -5.039681 2.413% 5 / 1

Gaussian and top-hat controls were matched to the Plummer kernel's 3D half-mass radius and used the same frozen ff and η\eta; they received no control-specific tuning. Plummer was better in aggregate by 3.784186 chi-square versus Gaussian and 4.216532 versus top-hat in this lane. All three kernels improved 5/6 stable galaxies, so generic low-pass redistribution remains a live explanation. The one-sided 5/6 equal-sign-null value is 0.109375; no confirmatory significance claim is made.

That aggregate rank is not a per-galaxy specificity result. Plummer beat both matched controls on only 3/6 stable galaxies. NGC5585 supplied 75.58% of the aggregate baseline chi-square and 103.24% of the total Plummer-over-Gaussian aggregate advantage. All three kernels worsened NGC5585; Plummer simply worsened it less, while the remaining galaxies net favored Gaussian. The selected f=1.0 is the full-smoothed-profile replacement endpoint of the declared operator family, not the earlier partial f=0.30 mixture. The deterministic per-unit receipt is aggregate_specificity_audit.json.

Heldout galaxy rows

Galaxy RdiskR_{\rm disk} kpc dd kpc Baseline χ2\chi^2 Plummer χ2\chi^2 Δχ2\Delta\chi^2 Reduction
UGC00731 2.300 0.28750 3.395909 2.781993 -0.613917 18.08%
NGC5585 1.530 0.19125 157.838322 160.027760 +2.189439 -1.39%
F574-1 4.460 0.55750 19.724808 12.339378 -7.385431 37.44%
UGC05721 0.380 0.04750 20.237618 17.934212 -2.303406 11.38%
UGC06446 1.490 0.18625 3.220346 2.910741 -0.309606 9.61%
DDO064 0.690 — 6.649968 excluded — baseline fit hit a bound
UGC12632 2.420 0.30250 4.427925 3.594632 -0.833293 18.82%

Executed-path verification

  • dev/heldout overlap: 0;
  • frozen policy preceded heldout evaluation;
  • f = 0 maximum prediction difference: 0;
  • deterministic heldout replay: byte-identical;
  • heldout artifact and replay SHA-256: ab92c3142a9498fcbe1583f225bbbc2d463442e65a81e565ba85f9e4cbe1d13b;
  • independent aggregate recomputation: pass, maximum discrepancy 5.7×10−145.7\times10^{-14};
  • maximum raw finite-grid mass leakage: 0.0053465 (0.535%);
  • maximum post-renormalization leakage: 3.204×10−153.204\times10^{-15};
  • operator tests: 8/8 pass;
  • R2 selected-source pre/post executed-path gates: pass.
  • public download-and-rerun path: numerically matched the stored development optimum and all heldout/control aggregates within 10−1210^{-12}; see sparc_rotation_curve_public_reproduction_check.json.

The original scientific executor code is published byte-for-byte under scripts/sparc/. The public helper is explicitly separated from the non-redistributed R2 proof authority.

Preserved failure and revision history

Four pre-heldout issues are retained rather than erased:

  1. a loader-order bug attempted to read an ineligible short curve before the metadata filter; it was repaired before scientific scoring;
  2. the initial finite-grid integration violated the numerical mass gate; the radial grid was increased from 1600 to 3200 points and one deterministic mass renormalization was introduced, while raw leakage remained visible and hard-gated;
  3. NumPy boolean fields prevented JSON serialization after dev computation; only native-boolean conversion changed;
  4. the first dev optimum hit the original f upper and eta lower grid edges; the development grid was expanded before heldout access, without changing the equation, kernel, objective, or sample.

See sparc_rotation_curve_failure_ledger.json.

Claim boundary

Supported

The frozen galaxy-scaled density adapter reduced aggregate heldout residuals under this implementation and selected score. Plummer was the best of the three frozen matched kernels in aggregate on the six stable heldout galaxies; that arithmetic ordering is conditional and is not adopted as kernel-specific evidence because the per-galaxy count was 3/6 and the aggregate advantage was concentrated in one adverse row.

Not established

  • a new physical source or law;
  • clean end-to-end prediction, because per-galaxy NFW nuisance parameters were fitted on each heldout rotation curve;
  • confirmatory statistical significance;
  • universal Plummer specificity;
  • replacement or falsification of NFW, baryonic models, GR, or LambdaCDM.

The exact result class remains a public-data shared-adapter diagnostic.