CHAPTER IX

Corrective direct formal-source spherical-Jeans rerun

All chapters

Why this record exists

This record answers the canonical-equation question directly: the operator is inserted into the three-dimensional NFW halo-density source of the unchanged spherical Jeans equation. A superseded internal response-space prototype is not part of the public benchmark record.

Equation comparison

Baseline:

d(νσr2)dr+2βrνσr2=−νGMbase(<r)r2,Mbase=M⋆+MNFW.\frac{d(\nu\sigma_r^2)}{dr}+\frac{2\beta}{r}\nu\sigma_r^2 =-\nu\frac{G M_{\rm base}(<r)}{r^2}, \qquad M_{\rm base}=M_\star+M_{\rm NFW}.

Direct orthogonal density and mass:

ρ⊥(r)=f[(Kd∗ρNFW)(r)−ρNFW(r)],\rho_\perp(r)=f\left[(K_d*\rho_{\rm NFW})(r)-\rho_{\rm NFW}(r)\right],
M⊥(<r)=4π∫0rρ⊥(r′)r′2dr′.M_\perp(<r)=4\pi\int_0^r\rho_\perp(r')r'^2dr'.

Augmented equation:

d(νσr2)dr+2βrνσr2=−νG[Mbase(<r)+M⊥(<r)]r2.\frac{d(\nu\sigma_r^2)}{dr}+\frac{2\beta}{r}\nu\sigma_r^2 =-\nu\frac{G\left[M_{\rm base}(<r)+M_\perp(<r)\right]}{r^2}.

Equivalently, rho_h,aug=(1-f)rho_NFW+f(K_d*rho_NFW). The operator acts on the three-dimensional NFW halo density only. Stellar mass and tracer density are not convolved. No response projection or free residual map is used.

Development calibration

Carina, Fornax, Sculptor, and Sextans were development galaxies. The shared search covered f in {0, 0.05, ..., 1} and eta in {0.03125, ..., 8}, with d_g=eta*r_half,g.

  • Safe optimum: f=0, eta=0.03125, exact baseline preservation.
  • Best nonzero diagnostic: f=0.05, eta=0.03125.
  • The nonzero diagnostic worsened the development macro score; only 1/4 development galaxies improved. It was frozen only to measure direct direction on the corrective evaluation set, not adopted.

Corrective Draco / Ursa Minor evaluation

Kernel Baseline chi-square Candidate chi-square Raw delta Residual reduction Improved / worsened
3D Plummer 22.835647795309 22.834488396426 -0.001159398883 0.005077% 2 / 0
half-mass-matched 3D Gaussian 22.835647795309 22.835485869669 -0.000161925641 0.000709% 2 / 0
half-mass-matched 3D top-hat 22.835647795309 22.835525851232 -0.000121944077 0.000534% 2 / 0
safe Plummer (f=0) 22.835647795309 22.835647795309 0 0% 0 / 0
Galaxy Baseline Plummer candidate Delta
Draco 13.087048844286 13.086373170862 -0.000675673424
Ursa Minor 9.748598951023 9.748115225564 -0.000483725459

Audit and replay

  • OmarAGI R2 executed-source pre/post gates: PASS.
  • Direct equation/source identity: PASS.
  • Response-adapter callable absent: PASS.
  • Exact f=0 prediction recovery: PASS.
  • Finite-grid mass-conservation gates: PASS.
  • Arithmetic and object-identity audit: 61/61 checks PASS.
  • Fresh-process replay preserved policy identity, delta signs, and direction counts. Floating-point outputs were numerically equivalent but not byte identical because the baseline L-BFGS-B fits shifted at sub-micro parameter scale.
  • The packaged public evaluation replay reproduced all four aggregate raw deltas and direction counts exactly (max raw-delta difference = 0).

Proof boundary

Label: CORRECT_FORMAL_SOURCE_DIRECTIONAL_DELTA_NEGATIVE_BUT_MATERIALITY_NOT_ESTABLISHED.

Draco and Ursa Minor had already been exposed during a superseded internal prototype, so this is a post-exposure corrective reproduction, not fresh/unseen proof. The development-safe decision remained f=0; the nonzero candidate is not adopted. The approximately 0.0051% reduction is a small forced-direction diagnostic, not material uplift, unique-kernel evidence, or a physical/cosmological claim. Candidate nuisance parameters were not refit.