CHAPTER X

X-COP direct hydrostatic-equation lane

All chapters

Live object

This lane compares the canonical hydrostatic-equilibrium equation with the same equation after a three-dimensional orthogonal redistribution is inserted only into the reconstructed dark-halo density.

It corrects the earlier off-object failure mode in which a projected proxy or response-space transformation could be mistaken for a direct equation insertion.

Baseline equation

The electron-pressure hydrostatic equation is

dPedr=−μmpne(r)GMNFW,total(<r)r2.\frac{dP_e}{dr} = -\mu m_p n_e(r)\frac{G M_{\mathrm{NFW,total}}(<r)}{r^2}.

The published X-COP hydrostatic NFW profile is the baseline gravitating mass.

Orthogonal-augmented equation

The dark-halo component is reconstructed as

ρdm(r)=ρNFW,total(r)−ρgas(r)−ρ⋆(r).\rho_{\rm dm}(r) = \rho_{\mathrm{NFW,total}}(r) -\rho_{\rm gas}(r) -\rho_\star(r).

The normalized three-dimensional Plummer kernel acts on this component only:

ρdm,aug(r)=(1−f)ρdm(r)+f(Kd∗ρdm)(r).\rho_{\rm dm,aug}(r) = (1-f)\rho_{\rm dm}(r) +f(K_d*\rho_{\rm dm})(r).

Equivalently, the mass correction is

ΔM⊥(<r)=f[M[Kd∗ρdm](<r)−M[ρdm](<r)],\Delta M_\perp(<r) = f\left[ M[K_d*\rho_{\rm dm}](<r)-M[\rho_{\rm dm}](<r) \right],

and the scored augmented equation is

dPedr=−μmpne(r)G[MNFW,total(<r)+ΔM⊥(<r)]r2.\frac{dP_e}{dr} = -\mu m_p n_e(r) \frac{G\left[M_{\mathrm{NFW,total}}(<r)+\Delta M_\perp(<r)\right]}{r^2}.

Gas, stars, electron-density data, and the pressure score are unchanged. f=0 recovers the baseline exactly.

Source and eligibility

Seven clusters contain every component required by the frozen reconstruction: X-ray pressure, electron density, hydrostatic NFW mass, gas-mass profile, and stellar-mass profile.

The fixed component-validity window is 0.005 <= r/R500 <= 3.0. The first preflight attempt stopped before producing scores when extrapolated baryonic subtraction became nonphysical beyond this shared support window. The repaired window was fixed across all eligible clusters before development optimization; no equation, kernel, sample, parameter grid, score, or matched control was changed.

Development and heldout lock

The deterministic name-hash split is:

  • Development: A2319, A85, ZW1215, A2142.
  • Heldout: A644, A2029, A1795.
  • Overlap: 0.
  • Sample identity SHA-256: 8285acec7f246c2681deaaae007eb3f9f4e94cef33892d3fdd14e01171bd2538.

The shared development grid was:

  • f in {0, .05, .10, .20, .30, .40, .50, .60, .75, 1.0}
  • d/R500 in {.005, .01, .02, .04, .08, .16}

The selected policy was f=1.0, d=0.01 R500. The fraction reached the declared upper grid boundary. The grid was not widened after heldout scoring.

The public source was accessible during development. “Heldout” means no heldout baseline or candidate score was executed before the shared policy was frozen; it does not imply secret data.

Score

The score is diagonal X-COP X-ray electron-pressure chi-square. A single additive pressure-boundary nuisance is profiled analytically with the same budget in both arms.

Heldout result

Cluster Points Baseline chi-square Augmented chi-square Raw delta Residual reduction
A644 12 46.162435 42.699543 -3.462892 7.5015%
A2029 14 58.109244 58.053889 -0.055354 0.0953%
A1795 13 40.823629 39.984353 -0.839276 2.0559%
Total 39 145.095308 140.737785 -4.357523 3.0032%

All three heldout clusters moved in the favorable direction. There was no heldout row fallback and no heldout downlift.

Matched generic controls

At the same frozen f and a half-mass-matched three-dimensional scale:

Kernel Augmented chi-square Raw delta Residual reduction Improved
Plummer 140.737785 -4.357523 3.0032% 3/3
Gaussian 142.042268 -3.053040 2.1042% 3/3
Top-hat 142.806793 -2.288515 1.5773% 3/3

Plummer is strongest in aggregate under this frozen comparison, but every generic smoother also improves all three clusters. The result therefore does not establish unique Plummer physics.

The aggregate ordering is not a per-cluster specificity result. Plummer beat both matched controls on only 1/3 clusters. A644 supplied 144.57% of the total Plummer-over-Gaussian aggregate advantage, while A2029 and A1795 net favored Gaussian. The selected f=1.0 is the full-smoothed-profile replacement endpoint, not the legacy partial f=0.30 mixture. The deterministic recomputation is in aggregate_specificity_audit.json.

Verification

  • Direct formal-equation insertion: PASS.
  • Dark-halo-only object lock: PASS.
  • True three-dimensional Plummer kernel: PASS.
  • Exact f=0 mass and pressure-prediction recovery: PASS.
  • Corrected mass conservation: PASS.
  • No heldout row fallback: PASS.
  • Deterministic byte-identical replay: PASS.
  • R2 source-authority pre-gate: PASS.
  • Executed-source post-gate: PASS.
  • Internal arithmetic self-audit: PASS.
  • Internal execution-path adversarial self-audit: PASS.
  • Independent external audit: not established in the stored result artifacts.

Evidence and claim boundary

The X-COP hydrostatic NFW mass profiles were reconstructed from the same thermodynamic profile family used in the pressure consistency score. This is therefore a public-profile direct-equation diagnostic, not an independent raw observational likelihood.

Supported:

On three untouched X-COP cluster profiles, the development-frozen direct halo-only orthogonal insertion moved hydrostatic pressure chi-square from 145.0953 to 140.7378 (delta -4.3575; 3.00% residual reduction), with negative delta in 3/3 clusters and no heldout downlift.

Not supported:

  • detection of a new source or physical law;
  • proof that the term is required by the data;
  • unique validation of Plummer geometry;
  • independent raw-observational proof;
  • a universal no-downlift guarantee.

Reproduction

See scripts/xcop_hse/README.md. Machine-readable contracts, policy, rows, controls, and audit receipts are under results/.