CHAPTER VI

Experiment registry and independence map

All chapters

The registry contains twelve experimental records, not twelve independent confirmations.

Record Stored units Independence status Result class
N13 development chain 5 clusters / one reused likelihood Development-only M1 within null; M2 absorbs residual
Program C H(z) 31 H(z) rows Separate dataset, different term No real uplift
Program EA weak-field/lensing 5 clusters Same N13 sample Same-sample diagnostic
Canonical equation channels 6 named channels Overlapping objectives; not 6 datasets Placement/channel audit
AS1063 true-density B2 1 public model pair Model-component diagnostic Directional reduction; specificity unresolved
HFF map transfer 6 clusters Six targets, shared teams/systematics Generic low-pass effect
SIDM Concerto Halo000 1 public simulation-parametric target New target Direction pass; specificity fail
SIDM Concerto Halo352 1 score-blind fresh target New target Direction pass; specificity fail
SPARC rotation-curve adapter 14 dev / 7 heldout; 6 stable heldout New public-data domain; shared adapter held out, per-galaxy nuisances fitted 4.432% aggregate heldout reduction; f=1 endpoint; Plummer beats both controls per unit 3/6
Dwarf-spheroidal spherical-Jeans adapter 2 dev / 2 heldout New public-data domain; shared adapter held out, per-galaxy nuisances fitted Adopted safe policy selected f=0; only the unadopted forced diagnostic slightly worsened both heldout galaxies
Direct formal-source Jeans insertion 4 dev / 2 post-exposure evaluation Draco/Ursa Minor identities were previously exposed; direct-source scores were new but not fresh/unseen Correct canonical object: both deltas negative, aggregate reduction 0.005077%; dev-safe policy remained f=0; materiality not established
X-COP direct hydrostatic-equation insertion 4 dev / 3 untouched-cluster heldout New public-profile domain; shared f/eta frozen, cluster identities untouched by score before freeze 145.095308 → 140.737785 chi-square; 3.0032% reduction; f=1 endpoint; Plummer beats both controls per unit 1/3

Development chain

The initial five-cluster likelihood was reused across M0/M1/M2/M3, Program EA, and several canonical-channel views. Renaming an objective or slicing channels does not create a new empirical unit. The public registry keeps those related rows together.

Direction versus specificity

Two questions are deliberately separated:

  1. Directional: did the frozen augmented profile reduce the chosen residual?
  2. Specificity: did the Plummer kernel beat half-mass-matched Gaussian and top-hat controls under the frozen comparison rule?

The strongest fresh 3D run passed the first question and failed the second. Therefore the current durable result is a generic redistribution effect under the selected diagnostic, not Plummer-specific evidence.

SPARC shared-adapter lane

SPARC adds a new observational domain and freezes one shared f/eta policy after development before evaluating the heldout galaxy identities. This is stronger than replaying the same development rows, but the heldout boundary does not cover each galaxy's baseline NFW nuisance fit. One of seven heldout baselines hit a bound and is retained as an excluded row. The valid public label is PUBLIC_DATA_DEV_OPTIMIZATION_PLUS_HELDOUT_SHARED_ADAPTER_DIAGNOSTIC.

The selected fraction was f=1.0, the full-smoothed-profile replacement endpoint rather than the legacy partial f=0.30 mixture. Plummer ranked first in aggregate, but beat both matched controls on only 3/6 stable galaxies. NGC5585 alone contributed 103.24% of the total Plummer-over-Gaussian aggregate advantage; all kernels worsened that galaxy and the other rows net favored Gaussian. The aggregate ordering is preserved as arithmetic but is not classified as kernel-specific evidence.

Dwarf-spheroidal Jeans lane

The Walker et al. public stellar-velocity catalogs add another equation and data domain. Sextans and Fornax calibrated a shared f/eta grid; Sculptor and Carina were held out from shared-policy selection. Calibration selected f=0, so the adopted policy exactly preserved the baseline and produced no adopted downlift. A separately frozen forced-nonzero branch was retained only as a non-adopted diagnostic. As in SPARC, each heldout object's own baseline NFW and anisotropy nuisances were fitted, so the lane is not clean end-to-end prediction.

Direct formal-source Jeans lane

This lane inserts rho_perp=f(K_d*rho_NFW-rho_NFW) into the halo-density source of the unchanged Jeans equation. Carina, Fornax, Sculptor, and Sextans calibrated the direct shared f/eta grid; the safe optimum was f=0. The best frozen nonzero diagnostic (f=0.05, eta=0.03125) moved Draco and Ursa Minor from 22.835647795309 to 22.834488396426 chi-square (delta=-0.001159398883, 0.005077%, 2/0 direction). Because those galaxy identities had already been exposed during an earlier superseded internal prototype, the result remains POST_EXPOSURE_CORRECTIVE_FORMAL_SOURCE_REPRODUCTION, not a new independent validation.

X-COP direct hydrostatic-equation lane

Seven official X-COP public cluster profiles contained every component required for the direct equation comparison. A deterministic name-hash split assigned four clusters to development and three cluster identities to heldout. The shared grid selected f=1.0, d=0.01 R500 before any heldout baseline or candidate score was executed.

On A644, A2029, and A1795, the direct dark-halo-only insertion changed aggregate pressure chi-square from 145.095308 to 140.737785 (delta=-4.357523, 3.0032%) with 3/3 negative deltas and no row-level fallback. Half-mass-matched Gaussian and top-hat controls also improved all three clusters, although Plummer was strongest in aggregate. The lane is therefore a heldout shared-operator public-profile consistency diagnostic, not an independent raw-observational likelihood or a Plummer-specific physical validation.

The selected f=1.0 is the full-replacement endpoint. Per cluster, Plummer beat both matched controls on only 1/3 rows. A644 supplied 144.57% of the total Plummer-over-Gaussian aggregate advantage; A2029 and A1795 net favored Gaussian. This aggregate-masking result is recorded in aggregate_specificity_audit.json.