{
  "base_chi_total": 0.06430745215227995,
  "checks": {
    "adoption_gate_present": false,
    "coarse_points": 801,
    "deterministic_no_rng_no_optimizer_no_fallback": true,
    "f0_recovery_max_abs_density_error": 0.0,
    "fine_points": 1601,
    "gold_or_score_visible_to_adoption_gate": false,
    "identity_branch_recovery_max_abs_density_error": 0.0,
    "max_coarse_fine_abs_chi_total": 2.000485514047634e-08
  },
  "claim_boundary": "Simulation-parametric model-to-model diagnostic; not an observational likelihood or physical detection.",
  "d_kpc": 16.0,
  "decision_rule": {
    "control_recovery_fraction_boundary": 0.8,
    "fail": "either matched control matches or beats Plummer within tolerance",
    "otherwise": "unresolved",
    "pass": "Plummer beats both controls beyond tolerance and best control recovers <80% of Plummer improvement",
    "score_tolerance_abs_chi_total": 1e-06
  },
  "direction_verdict": "INDEPENDENT_3D_DIRECTIONAL_TRANSFER_PASS",
  "evidence_class": "INDEPENDENT_PUBLIC_SIMULATION_PARAMETRIC_3D_HALO_COMPONENT_DIAGNOSTIC_NOT_OBSERVATIONAL_LIKELIHOOD",
  "f_perp": 0.3,
  "interpretation": "This score-blind fresh target reproduced a large directional reduction. Gaussian and top-hat improved more than Plummer. Because the target is a cored profile and the baseline is cusped, the direction is mechanically favorable to low-pass redistribution; no operator-specific physics follows.",
  "kernels": {
    "gaussian_3d": {
      "chi_total": 0.03721538328132527,
      "coarse_fine_abs_chi_total": 2.000485514047634e-08,
      "deterministic_replay_max_abs_density_error": 0.0,
      "downlift": false,
      "raw_delta_chi_total": -0.02709206887095468,
      "relative_augmented_mass_leakage": -0.0009459650388761957,
      "residual_reduction_pct": 42.12897255951099
    },
    "plummer_3d": {
      "chi_total": 0.03794154343683144,
      "coarse_fine_abs_chi_total": 0.0,
      "deterministic_replay_max_abs_density_error": 0.0,
      "downlift": false,
      "raw_delta_chi_total": -0.026365908715448513,
      "relative_augmented_mass_leakage": -0.0012855487838253385,
      "residual_reduction_pct": 40.999771928475845
    },
    "tophat_3d": {
      "chi_total": 0.03692478129118461,
      "coarse_fine_abs_chi_total": 2.610771078492835e-09,
      "deterministic_replay_max_abs_density_error": 0.0,
      "downlift": false,
      "raw_delta_chi_total": -0.027382670861095346,
      "relative_augmented_mass_leakage": -0.0009500838003960909,
      "residual_reduction_pct": 42.58086729396963
    }
  },
  "matching": {
    "criterion": "analytic three-dimensional half-mass radius",
    "gaussian_r_half_kpc": 20.87625642406571,
    "gaussian_sigma_kpc": 13.572118703611515,
    "plummer_r_half_kpc": 20.87625642406571,
    "tophat_r_half_kpc": 20.87625642406571,
    "tophat_radius_kpc": 26.30243491168346
  },
  "object_X": "rho_halo only: Group_Halo352 primary-host CDM NFW density reconstructed from public cdmVmaxz0/cdmRmaxz0",
  "operator": "rho_aug=(1-f_perp)rho_halo+f_perp(K*rho_halo)",
  "prior_overlap": {
    "current_target": "Group_Halo352",
    "prior_development_target": "LCluster_Halo000",
    "same_target": false
  },
  "proof_mode": "FRESH_SCORE_BLIND_SIMULATION_PARAMETRIC_KERNEL_SPECIFICITY_DIAGNOSTIC",
  "record_id": "SIDM_CONCERTO_HALO352_FRESH_3D",
  "reference_object": "matched Group_Halo352 primary-host public parametric SIDM 3D density prediction using rhoss1/rss1/rc1 and beta=4",
  "score_function": "frozen B2 weighted log-MSE: 0.35*rho_log_MSE + 0.65*cumulative_mass_log_MSE over 3-800 kpc",
  "source": {
    "archive_md5_verified": true,
    "dataset": "SIDM Concerto Group Halo352 public parametric release",
    "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.14933624",
    "official_archive_md5": "100863ce7e3284c5b39107e6e8a9f285",
    "prior_repo_overlap_before_import": 0,
    "source_table_sha256": "d8149f2883dd06c6e4fab464b712391b46c2a3d583a5f8953348851a6e4af380",
    "source_tar_sha256": "950a5ca7840b1e8b003008fc7ac1024f2b40a487a3d008ce040b923cf7ec1430",
    "target_ids": {
      "cdmID": 1,
      "vd100id": 1
    },
    "target_lock": {
      "replacement_on_missing": "ABORT",
      "target_locked_before_download": true
    },
    "zenodo_record": "https://zenodo.org/records/14933624"
  },
  "source_row": {
    "cdmID": 1.0,
    "cdmRmaxz0": 89.88357142857144,
    "cdmRvirz0": 609.4957142857143,
    "cdmVmaxz0": 361.25,
    "mcdm": 12797142857142.857,
    "mint": 12797534135874.984,
    "msidm": 12720000000000.0,
    "rc1": 17.0121255535864,
    "rhoss1": 10613257.068419646,
    "rmax": 89.5604053855214,
    "rmax1": 89.91464192417449,
    "rss1": 34.55070619886563,
    "rt1": 10000000000.0,
    "tr0": 0.07764206651876804,
    "tr1": 0.05639302473869122,
    "trx": 0.058800432385497,
    "vd100Rmaxz0": 90.22628571428572,
    "vd100Vmaxz0": 370.05,
    "vd100id": 1.0,
    "vmax": 365.6912841990707,
    "vmax1": 364.73537722953637
  },
  "specificity_verdict": "INDEPENDENT_3D_PLUMMER_SPECIFICITY_FAIL",
  "upstream_artifact_sha256": "47bca0415053ccdb14f5c66fcda4be1e3d2726adea098d87273dbbe5808357e9"
}
