# Claim boundaries

## Supported

- The operator and equation insertions are explicit and reproducible.
- Baseline recovery, deterministic replay, numerical convergence, finite-grid leakage, and matched controls are recorded where applicable.
- In the published model-product and simulation-parametric diagnostics, the frozen redistribution operator often reduced the selected residual metric.
- The HFF map direction is explained by generic low-pass redistribution under the present comparison.
- The fresh Halo352 result is a clean directional diagnostic and a clean Plummer-specificity failure.
- In the SPARC shared-adapter heldout lane, the frozen Plummer adapter reduced
  aggregate chi-square by 9.256213 (4.432%) and improved 5/6 stable galaxies.
- The dwarf-spheroidal Jeans calibration selected the exact baseline (`f=0`),
  so the adopted policy had no downlift. A separately reported, unadopted
  forced-nonzero diagnostic slightly worsened both heldout galaxies.
- The corrective direct formal-source rerun executed the requested spherical-Jeans source insertion without response projection. Its frozen nonzero Plummer diagnostic moved both Draco and Ursa Minor deltas negative (`delta chi-square = -0.001159399`; `0.005077%` residual reduction), while the development-safe policy remained `f=0`.
- The X-COP direct hydrostatic-equation run applied the operator only to
  reconstructed three-dimensional dark-halo density and retained the
  canonical hydrostatic equation. After shared-policy freeze, aggregate
  heldout pressure chi-square moved from `145.095308` to `140.737785`
  (`delta=-4.357523`, `3.0032%`) with 3/3 negative cluster deltas and no
  row-level fallback.

## Conditional / limited

- AS1063 B2 shows a 19.857% public model-component residual reduction, but generic controls recover more than 94% of the gain.
- Cross-cluster HFF directions are six physical targets but share model teams, processing, and score design; they are not six methodologically independent experiments.
- The 2D and 3D kernels have different lineages and are not one identical physical operator.
- The SPARC heldout status applies to shared `f/eta` only. Every heldout galaxy
  still received a fitted NFW baseline, one of seven baselines was unstable,
  and the 5/6 sign result is not confirmatory (`p = 0.109375` under an
  independent equal-sign null).
- The SPARC development optimum reached the declared `f=1.0` boundary. This is
  the full-smoothed-profile replacement endpoint of the declared family, not
  the earlier partial `f=0.30` mixture.
- Plummer beat the two frozen matched generic controls in SPARC aggregate
  chi-square, but it beat both controls per galaxy in only 3/6 stable rows.
  NGC5585 supplied 103.24% of the aggregate Plummer-over-Gaussian advantage
  while all three kernels worsened that galaxy; the remaining rows net favored
  Gaussian. The aggregate ordering is arithmetic, not kernel-specific evidence.
- The Jeans heldout label applies only to shared `f/eta`; each heldout galaxy
  received its own baseline NFW and constant-anisotropy nuisance fit. Its
  nonzero deltas are materially negligible and do not support adapter adoption.
- The corrective direct-source run is post-exposure because Draco and Ursa
  Minor had already been used during a superseded internal prototype.
  Candidate nuisances were frozen at the baseline fit; this is a forced
  directional comparison, not a best-fit augmented-model or fresh/unseen
  test. The absolute effect is materially small.
- The X-COP heldout boundary applies to the shared `f/eta` policy and cluster
  identities. The source profiles were public and physically accessible.
  X-COP hydrostatic NFW profiles were reconstructed from the same
  thermodynamic profile family used by the pressure consistency score, so the
  lane is not an independent raw-observational likelihood.
- The X-COP development optimum reached the declared `f=1.0` grid boundary.
  The grid was not widened after heldout scoring. As in SPARC, this is the
  full-smoothed-profile replacement endpoint rather than the legacy partial
  `f=0.30` mixture.
- Matched Gaussian and top-hat controls also improved all three X-COP heldout
  clusters. Plummer was strongest in aggregate but beat both controls on only
  1/3 clusters. A644 supplied 144.57% of the aggregate
  Plummer-over-Gaussian advantage while A2029 and A1795 net favored Gaussian.
  Unique kernel physics is not established.

## Not supported

- Treating the Vision Pro observation or Einstein-Rosen topological
  inspiration as cosmological evidence, a physical derivation of the
  operator, or evidence for a white hole, wormhole, hidden sheet, or extra
  dimension.
- Detection of an orthogonal source, hidden sheet, or new stress-energy component.
- Plummer-specific physics.
- Einstein-equation or cosmological proof.
- Replacement or falsification of GR, LambdaCDM, NFW, or baryonic countermodels.
- Raw-observational-likelihood improvement from model-to-model diagnostic scores.
- Treating overlapping channels or repeated development runs as independent validations.
- Treating the corrective `0.005077%` Jeans reduction as material uplift, adoption evidence, kernel specificity, or physical proof.
- Treating the X-COP profile-consistency result as independent raw-likelihood
  proof, proof that the term is required, a universal no-downlift guarantee,
  or unique Plummer validation.

## Public sentence

> A frozen orthogonal redistribution term reduced several frozen model-to-model residual metrics, but matched generic smoothers reproduced or exceeded the strongest gains; the current result is a reproducible generic redistribution diagnostic, not evidence for a new physical term.

The SPARC-specific sentence is:

> A development-selected galaxy-scaled redistribution adapter reduced aggregate residuals on a heldout SPARC subset by 4.432%, while matched generic smoothers also improved the same 5/6 stable galaxies; this is a shared-adapter diagnostic, not clean predictive or physical proof.

For kernel comparisons, append:

> The selected policy was the `f=1` full-replacement endpoint. Plummer ranked
> first in aggregate but beat both matched controls in only 3/6 stable galaxies,
> with the aggregate advantage concentrated in NGC5585; this does not establish
> Plummer specificity.

The dwarf-spheroidal Jeans-specific sentence is:

> On a public-data spherical-Jeans dev/heldout diagnostic, calibration selected the unmodified baseline (`f=0`), so the adopted policy exactly preserved baseline performance; a separately frozen, unadopted nonzero diagnostic was slightly adverse.

The corrective direct-formal Jeans sentence is:

> The direct halo-density insertion moved both post-exposure Draco and Ursa Minor deltas slightly negative (`22.835648 → 22.834488` chi-square), but development selected `f=0` and the aggregate reduction was only `0.005077%`; this is a corrected equation-object diagnostic, not material uplift or fresh proof.

The X-COP hydrostatic-equation sentence is:

> On three untouched X-COP cluster profiles, the development-frozen direct
> halo-only orthogonal insertion moved hydrostatic pressure chi-square from
> `145.095308` to `140.737785` (`delta=-4.357523`; `3.0032%` residual
> reduction), with negative delta in 3/3 clusters and no heldout downlift;
> this is a public-profile direct-equation diagnostic, not independent
> raw-observational or physical proof.

For kernel comparisons, append:

> The selected policy was the `f=1` full-replacement endpoint. Plummer ranked
> first in aggregate but beat both matched controls in only 1/3 clusters, with
> the aggregate advantage concentrated in A644; this does not establish
> Plummer specificity.
